Butler
feels
like home
A quiet retreat on High Street, steps from Lake Hopatcong. Comfortable rooms, unhurried mornings, and the kind of stillness that makes you want to stay a little longer.
Near
Lake Hopatcong
Quiet
Butler, NJ
Comfort
Every stay
"The kind of place where you actually hear yourself think — and that's a good thing."
— High Crest Lake Lodge
Rooms designed
for rest
Every room at High Crest Lake Lodge is furnished with care — clean lines, soft textures, and the quiet comfort of a home away from home. We keep it simple so you can focus on what matters: your time here.
Standard Queen
A peaceful retreat with a plush queen bed, work desk, and all the essentials for a restful stay.
King Suite
Extra space with a king bed, sitting area, and oversized windows that let in morning light.
Accessible Room
Thoughtfully designed for guests with mobility needs — wider doors, grab bars, and barrier-free access.
For availability and rates, please call us directly.
(973) 838-1288
Butler is a
great place
to be
Nestled in Sussex County, Butler sits on the shores of Lake Hopatcong — New Jersey's largest lake. Whether you're here for the summer water sports, the autumn foliage, or simply the silence of a winter morning, there's a rhythm to this place that settles into you.
High Crest Lake Lodge is right in the center of it all — close to restaurants, local shops, and the lake, yet tucked away enough that you hear only birdsong and the wind.
- Lake Hopatcong — boating, fishing, and swimming in summer
- Walking trails and parks within minutes
- Local dining and seasonal events in Butler
- Easy access to Morristown and the Jersey Shore
Everything you
need, nothing
you don't
We don't clutter the experience with things you'll never use. What we do offer, we do well — because comfort shouldn't require a manual.
Free Wi-Fi
Reliable internet throughout the property — for work, streaming, or staying in touch.
Fresh Linens
Crisp, clean linens changed between every stay — because the small things matter.
Easy Parking
Complimentary on-site parking — pull up, unload, and settle in without the hassle.
Lake Access
Short drive to Lake Hopatcong — bring your gear and make the most of the water.
The best part of staying somewhere isn't the amenities — it's the feeling that you've found exactly what you needed, without anything extra getting in the way.
High Crest Lake Lodge, Butler
Right on
High Street
Address
112 High St
Butler, NJ 07445-1134
Phone
(973) 838-1288Check-in
Please call ahead to arrange arrival
Your room
on High Street
Whether it's a weekend by the lake or a quiet week to yourself, High Crest Lake Lodge is ready when you are. Call us — we'll take care of the rest.
